Favorite all-season 4-6oz round/oblate/beefsteak tomatoes
Posted: Mon May 03, 2021 8:04 pm
What are your favorite 4 to 6 ounce round/oblate/beefsteak tomatoes that are either indeterminate or long-producing determinates (or semi-determinates), and why?
I think mine are currently these:
Current top favorites:
* Matina (early; great taste; vigorous plant)
* Early Girl F1 (prolific; early to early-ish; can be tasty; big harvest at the end of the season)
* Frittata Kitchen (early; prolific; great flavorful taste in cooking; sport of Bloody Butcher with the same plant/production habit, but different fruit; I favor FK over BB since FK has firmer fruits, stronger flavor, more seeds, and it's excellent in cooking--I use this size of tomato in cooking a lot; FK was a kind of weird taste fresh, though, but it's still good and flavorful, IMO; you know how bubblegum tastes weird? It's kind of that kind of weird, but it doesn't taste like bubblegum, exactly, and the weird flavor is only one of its flavor tones--the rest of the flavor is similar to Mountain Princess: tangy.)
Other favorites:
* Mountain Princess (early-ish; great taste; good production; plant clumps a lot at first, and takes a while to get very big, but then it grows nicely)
* Chocolate Chestnut (for taste; tastes like brown sugar; I hear it can be very prolific, but mine wasn't in 2020; trying again in 2021)
* Cosmic Eclipse (seems to be a good producer; soft fruit; while the taste wasn't a selling point for me, it's certainly edible; stripes; anthocyanin; round)
* Nodak Early (kind of like Mountain Princess, without the small/clumping start, firmer, rounder fruit, and milder, less-acidic taste)
* Sub Arctic Plenty (in containers, it can be prolific and have a good texture; might not produce all-season in areas with longer seasons, or where it matures earlier)
* Red Beauty (very attractive fruits, even before they're ripe, with decent production; tastes like tomato soup; about 70 days to ripe fruit, from the transplant; beefsteak shape; anthocynin and stripes)
* Bloody Butcher (fun to grow; soft fruits; mild but good novelty taste; produces less at the end of the season, but it produces all season long)
* New Yorker V (excellent taste; I need to grow it more to evaluate whether it produces all season)
* Manitoba (I need to grow it more to evaluate whether it produces all season)
* Lemon Boy F1 (Similar to Early Girl F1, but yellow, with longer internodes, somewhat bigger fruit, a much bigger plant, exceptionally long vines, and somewhat lower production.)
I think mine are currently these:
Current top favorites:
* Matina (early; great taste; vigorous plant)
* Early Girl F1 (prolific; early to early-ish; can be tasty; big harvest at the end of the season)
* Frittata Kitchen (early; prolific; great flavorful taste in cooking; sport of Bloody Butcher with the same plant/production habit, but different fruit; I favor FK over BB since FK has firmer fruits, stronger flavor, more seeds, and it's excellent in cooking--I use this size of tomato in cooking a lot; FK was a kind of weird taste fresh, though, but it's still good and flavorful, IMO; you know how bubblegum tastes weird? It's kind of that kind of weird, but it doesn't taste like bubblegum, exactly, and the weird flavor is only one of its flavor tones--the rest of the flavor is similar to Mountain Princess: tangy.)
Other favorites:
* Mountain Princess (early-ish; great taste; good production; plant clumps a lot at first, and takes a while to get very big, but then it grows nicely)
* Chocolate Chestnut (for taste; tastes like brown sugar; I hear it can be very prolific, but mine wasn't in 2020; trying again in 2021)
* Cosmic Eclipse (seems to be a good producer; soft fruit; while the taste wasn't a selling point for me, it's certainly edible; stripes; anthocyanin; round)
* Nodak Early (kind of like Mountain Princess, without the small/clumping start, firmer, rounder fruit, and milder, less-acidic taste)
* Sub Arctic Plenty (in containers, it can be prolific and have a good texture; might not produce all-season in areas with longer seasons, or where it matures earlier)
* Red Beauty (very attractive fruits, even before they're ripe, with decent production; tastes like tomato soup; about 70 days to ripe fruit, from the transplant; beefsteak shape; anthocynin and stripes)
* Bloody Butcher (fun to grow; soft fruits; mild but good novelty taste; produces less at the end of the season, but it produces all season long)
* New Yorker V (excellent taste; I need to grow it more to evaluate whether it produces all season)
* Manitoba (I need to grow it more to evaluate whether it produces all season)
* Lemon Boy F1 (Similar to Early Girl F1, but yellow, with longer internodes, somewhat bigger fruit, a much bigger plant, exceptionally long vines, and somewhat lower production.)